USNA 287A: Perspectives on the Cosmos: From the Ancient Philosophers to Modern Science

Course Work

Group Discussions
Considerable class time will be devoted to discussion. We will pose specific questions to debate, and discuss some issues in small groups prior to wider class discussion.

Short & Modest papers (1 - 3 pages*) on specified topics.

Final paper 10 pages*, on a topic of your choice.

Oral Presentations
In addition to daily participation, you will be give a formal presentation of your final research paper. These will be scheduled towards the end of the term.

Grading and due dates

10% Participation in Class Discussions ** (daily)
05% Short paper (1 page)
The Theistic & Anthropic Principles
Due Sep. 2.
15% Modest paper (3 pages)
Geocentric & Heliocentric Cosmologies
Peer review Sep. 23. Complete draft due to peers 9/22.
Due Sep. 25.
15% Modest paper (3 pages)
Cosmic Inflation
Peer review Oct. 21. Complete draft due to peers 10/20.
Due Oct. 23.
40% Final paper*** (10 pages)
Select a topic by Nov. 7
Annotated bibliography due Nov. 13 (5%).
Peer review Dec. 2. Complete draft due to peers 12/1.
Due Dec. 5 (the last day of classes).
Submit your papers by email by midnight Friday.
15% Oral Presentations
Nov. 18, 20, 25. Ten minute**** presentations based on your Final paper.


*One page is defined to be 250 words. Papers should be formatted in Times New Roman 12 pt. font, double-spaced, with 1" margins all-around. Papers should come within 10% of the specified length: a ten page paper may be 11 pages of text at most. Twelve pages is right out. The limit refers to text only; it excludes the bibliography and any figures. Each paper should employ MLA reference and in-text citation practices. This applies to all pieces of writing.

**Examples of class participation include, but are not limited to, engaging in class discussion with substantive ideas, questions, and insights, and contributions to group projects and discussions.
For the terribly shy: don't worry, this is not onerous. With 17 people in the class, the challenge is to get a word in edge-wise. For the loquacious: good - please express yourself. But also be respectful of your fellow students and don't overly monopolize the conversation.

***The topic of the final paper is your choice, in consultation with Prof. McGaugh. Dig into something that interests you. Each chapter of Hetherington's book could be the launching point for your paper. Here are a some further ideas for paper topics. You are not limited to these - the possibilities are endless. You could choose to explore the cosmology of a particular Ancient Philosopher, investigate the conflict between Galileo and the Catholic Church, or learn about modern ideas about multiverses.
You must discuss your interests directly with Professor McGaugh and obtain approval for your chosen topic.

There is no limitation on sources. You should use as many as you need. The textbook has many good references and is a good place to start. By the same token, in no case will the book suffice as the sole source. Indeed, you must not rely exclusively on a single source: at a minimum, your bibliography must include five sources.

****Ten pages may seem like a long paper, but ten minutes is a very short time in which to discuss your topic. Keep focussed! A schedule will be posted when topics are chosen: we will have our own mini-conference, organized by subject (to the extent possible).

Papers

The papers can be included in your SAGES portfolio, which "documents your progress as a writer over your first three SAGES seminars and provides the University with programmatic feedback that will be used to enhance future seminars" (SAGES Writing Portfolio Assignment, www.case.edu/sages/portfolio.html).